Un

I still remember the first time I booted up Hellblade 2, expecting this incredible gaming experience that would blend storytelling with engaging gameplay. The opening cinematic was absolutely breathtaking—the kind of visual masterpiece that makes you lean closer to your screen. But somewhere between the stunning visuals and atmospheric sound design, I started noticing this underlying problem that kept resurfacing throughout my 12-hour playthrough. The gameplay just couldn't quite match the quality of its storytelling, creating this frustrating disconnect that ultimately made the experience feel more like watching a slightly interactive movie than actually playing a game.

When you break it down, Hellblade 2's core activities sound perfectly reasonable on paper. Walking, puzzle-solving, and combat—these three elements have formed the foundation of countless successful games throughout gaming history. I mean, think about it: if you strip down something as beloved as The Legend of Zelda to its basic components, you'd find pretty much the same ingredients. Yet somehow, Ninja Theory managed to create an experience where these elements felt disconnected and unsatisfying. The pacing was just off, with long stretches of what felt like aimless wandering punctuated by brief moments of actual gameplay.

The walking segments became particularly problematic for me. I'd estimate about 65% of my playtime was spent slowly crawling through dark caves or trudging along picturesque but ultimately empty beaches. At first, I appreciated the atmospheric quality of these sections—the way Senua's breathing would sync with my own, the stunning visual details in every rock formation and wave pattern. But after the third or fourth extended walking sequence, I found myself checking my phone during these sections, which is never a good sign in an immersive narrative game. The environmental storytelling was there, but it couldn't carry the weight of these prolonged, uneventful stretches.

What made the walking segments particularly frustrating was how infrequently they transitioned into meaningful gameplay. The puzzles, when they did appear, were often too simplistic to provide any real mental stimulation. I remember one particular puzzle sequence around the 4-hour mark that involved aligning symbols—it looked visually impressive but required so little actual thought that I completed it almost automatically. These moments should have provided relief from the walking sections, but instead they felt like brief interruptions rather than engaging challenges. The lack of variety in puzzle types didn't help either—by the game's midpoint, I could predict exactly what each new puzzle would require.

Then there's the combat, which honestly surprised me with how basic it felt compared to the first game. The combat encounters were so sparse—I'd estimate only about 15-20 meaningful fights throughout the entire game—and each followed such a predictable pattern that they never evolved beyond their initial simplicity. Parry, dodge, attack—that's pretty much the entire combat system right there. I kept waiting for new mechanics to be introduced or for the difficulty to ramp up, but it never really happened. The visceral satisfaction I remembered from the original Hellblade's combat was noticeably absent, replaced by what felt like obligatory interludes between walking and puzzle sections.

What's interesting is that individually, none of these elements are necessarily bad. The walking creates atmosphere, the puzzles provide intellectual engagement, and the combat offers catharsis. But the way they're balanced and integrated creates this peculiar rhythm where no single element gets enough time to truly shine. The transitions between these activities often felt abrupt rather than seamless, constantly reminding me that I was playing a game composed of separate systems rather than experiencing a cohesive whole. It's that lack of flow that ultimately prevented me from feeling fully connected to Senua's journey.

I can't help but compare it to games that successfully blend similar elements— titles like God of War (2018) or even the recent Plague Tale games manage to balance narrative and gameplay in a way that keeps players engaged throughout. These games understand that even during quieter moments, players need to feel like their input matters. In Hellblade 2, there were stretches where I felt like I was just holding the stick forward while the game played itself, my involvement reduced to that of a spectator rather than an active participant.

Don't get me wrong—there were moments of genuine brilliance. The audio design remains unparalleled in gaming, with the binaural voices creating this incredibly immersive psychological experience. The graphical fidelity is arguably the best I've seen on current-generation hardware. But these technical achievements couldn't compensate for the fundamental gameplay issues that kept pulling me out of the experience. Around the 8-hour mark, I found myself pushing forward not because I was enjoying the gameplay, but because I wanted to see how the story resolved.

This brings me back to that central problem—the disconnect between Hellblade 2's phenomenal presentation and its underwhelming gameplay execution. When a game looks this good and tells such an important story, you want the gameplay to match that ambition. Instead, what we got feels like a step backward from the original in terms of mechanical depth and player engagement. The balance is just off, with too much emphasis on passive observation and not enough on meaningful interaction.

By the time I reached the credits, I felt this strange mix of admiration and disappointment. I appreciated what Ninja Theory was trying to accomplish from a narrative and technical perspective, but I couldn't shake the feeling that the actual "game" parts of this game needed more development time and attention. For players who prioritize storytelling above all else, Hellblade 2 might still be worth experiencing. But for those of us who believe gameplay should be the foundation of any interactive experience, it's hard not to see this as a missed opportunity to create something truly groundbreaking rather than just visually stunning.